Why Productivity Growth Is Faltering: Regulations Soaring; Enterprenuership Sinking

By John Dearie at the Manhattan Institute 

Three reports issued in recent weeks provide important, and worrisome, insight into the long-term health of the U.S. economy. If policymakers carefully consider each—and understand the connections between them—the U.S. economy stands a far better chance of returning to historical rates of economic growth and job creation.

Report #1: On May 7th, the Labor Department reported that productivity—output per hour worked—declined at an annual rate of 1.7 percent in the first quarter of this year. After growing at an average annual rate of about 2.5 percent since 1948, productivity growth has averaged only about 1.1 percent since 2011—less than half the historical trend.

The flagging rate of productivity growth is cause for concern because productivity drives economic growth and rising standards of living. In 1956, Nobel Laureate economist Robert Solow demonstrated that most of economic growth cannot be attributed to increases in capital and labor, but only to gains in productivity—gains driven by innovation. As businesses and workers become more efficient, costs fall, profits and incomes rise, demand expands, and economic growth and job creation accelerate.

Throughout modern economic history, entrepreneurs and the start-ups they launch have been the principal source of the innovation that drives productivity gains. For example, most of the radical innovations of the past 100 years—electrification, the railroad, the automobile, the airplane, the telegraph and telephone, air conditioning, the computer—the truly “disruptive” innovations that dramatically enhanced productivity and fundamentally re-made the economic landscape, came from entrepreneurs. Relatedly, recent research has demonstrated that start-ups have also accounted for virtually all net new job creation over the past three decades.

Report #2: Alarmingly, entrepreneurship in America is in trouble. In an important new paper released by the Brookings Institution on May 5th, economists Robert Litan and Ian Hathaway show that new business formation and businesses dynamism—the economically vital process by which firms continually launch, expand, contract, and fail—has been in persistent decline over the last few decades across a broad range of industry sectors, including high-technology, and in all 50 states. Given the critical role start-ups play as the principal source of innovation and job creation, this multi-decade decline in business dynamism is nothing short of a national economic emergency.

What might account for the decline in American entrepreneurship?

At roundtables we conducted with entrepreneurs in 12 cities across the United States, I and a colleague, Courtney Geduldig, heard a number of major themes everywhere we went—remarkable, given the size and diversity of the U.S. economy. One recurring message is that regulatory burden, complexity, and uncertainty is undermining entrepreneurs’ ability to successfully launch new businesses, expand, and create jobs.

“They can be federal, state, or local—and sometimes they conflict,” Alan Blake of Austin-based Yorktown Technologies told us. “Identifying, understanding, and complying with all these regulations is a huge loss of productivity…Entrepreneurs don’t have the resources to hire an in-house counsel or a chief financial officer. They're trying to do all of it themselves.”

“It’s as if the politicians and regulators in Washington want me to fail—and spend all their time thinking up new ways to ensure that I do,” said Sharon Delay, founder of Adjunct Solutions in Westerville, Ohio. “Quit throwing ridiculous roadblocks in front of me! You either want me to be the engine of the economy or you don’t!”

Report #3: “10,000 Commandments,” an annual assessment of the Federal regulatory burden compiled by Wayne Crews of the Competitive Enterprise Institute, issued on April 29th, confirms that the message from our roundtables is more than mere carping. Last year more than 3,600 new regulations were finalized and an additional 2,600 were proposed. Nearly 90,000 new final regulations have been promulgated over the past 20 years—an average of more than 4,300 each year. Crews estimates the overall cost of regulatory compliance and its economic impact to be $1.9 trillion annually—equivalent to the tenth largest economy on Earth.

Click here for complete article



John R. Dearie, Executive Vice President at the Financial Services Forum, is co-author, with Courtney Geduldig, Vice President of Global Regulatory Affairs at McGraw Hill Financial, Inc., of “Where the Jobs Are: Entrepreneurship and the Soul of the American Economy,” published by John Wiley & Sons. You can follow him on Twitter here.

David Stockman's Contra Corner is the only place where mainstream delusions and cant about the Warfare State, the Bailout State, Bubble Finance and Beltway Banditry are ripped, refuted and rebuked. Subscribe now to receive David Stockman’s latest posts by email each day as well as his model portfolio, Lee Adler’s Daily Data Dive and David’s personally curated insights and analysis from leading contrarian thinkers.

Get Access